Topic 2

Using dimensions to check an equation

You can only add or compare things of the same kind. Adding a length to a time makes no sense. So in a correct equation every term has the same dimensions. This is called the principle of homogeneity.

Predict first

Here s is a distance, u and v are speeds, a is an acceleration and t is a time. Which equation must be wrong?

To check an equation, work out the dimensions of each term on its own. If any term differs from the rest, the equation is wrong.

Checking s = u t + ½ a t²Step 1 / 4
s[L]a distanceu t½ a t²=+

Start with the left side. s is a distance, so its dimensions are [L].

Text version
  1. Start with the left side. s is a distance, so its dimensions are [L].
  2. u t is a speed times a time: [L T⁻¹] × [T]. The T⁻¹ and T cancel, leaving [L].
  3. In ½ a t², the ½ is a pure number with no dimensions. [L T⁻²] × [T²] leaves [L].
  4. Every term is [L], so the equation is dimensionally consistent. The check says nothing about whether ½ is the right number.

What the check cannot catch

Dimensions cannot see pure numbers. The check passes s = u t + a t² just as happily as s = u t + ½ a t². An equation that fails is certainly wrong; one that passes may still be wrong.